Exercise-ch6: Difference between revisions

From Lexical Resource Semantics
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 65: Line 65:


Provide the logical form of the following sentences. For the solutions, mark the -seemingly emtpy- line below the sentence with your mouse.
Provide the logical form of the following sentences. For the solutions, mark the -seemingly emtpy- line below the sentence with your mouse.
# Every student asked Alex.<br />Solution: <span style="color:#FFFFFF">&forall; ''x'' ('''student''' &bull; ''x'' : (('''help''' &bull; e) &bull; '''alex''') &bull; ''x'')</span>
# Sentence: ''Every student asked Alex.''<br />Logical form: <span style="color:#FFFFFF">&forall; ''x'' ('''student''' &bull; ''x'' : (('''help''' &bull; ''e'') &bull; '''alex''') &bull; ''x'')</span>
# Alex talked to Chris about many movies.<br />Solution: <span style="color:#FFFFFF">'''Many''' ''x'' ('''movie''' &bull; ''x'' : ((('''talk-to-about''' &bull; e) &bull; '''chris''') &bull; ''x'') &bull; '''alex''')</span>
# Sentence: ''Alex talked to Chris about many movies.''<br />Logical form: <span style="color:#FFFFFF">'''Many''' ''x'' ('''movie''' &bull; ''x'' : ((('''talk-to-about''' &bull; ''e'') &bull; '''chris''') &bull; ''x'') &bull; '''alex''')</span>
# Every student asked Alex.<br />Solution:  
# Sentence: ''Chomsky wrote at least four books that Alex has read.''<br />Logical form: <span style="color:#FFFFFF">
<span style="color:#FFFFFF">
'''AtLeast-4''' ''x'' (('''book''' &bull; ''x'' &and; (('''read''' &bull; ''e'') &bull; ''x'') &bull; '''alex''') : (('''write''' &bull; ''u'') &bull; ''x'') &bull; '''chomsky''')
&forall; ''x'' ('''student''' &bull; ''x'' : (('''help''' &bull; e) &bull; '''alex''') &bull; ''x'')
</span>
</span>


== LRS combinatorics for quantifiers ==
== LRS combinatorics for quantifiers ==

Revision as of 16:14, 19 November 2013

Exercises for chapter 6: Quantifiers

Quantifier denotation

Complete the paraphrase for the following sentences with quantifiers.

1 Sentence: Pat read many books.

For

x such that

is a

, Pat

x.

2 Sentence: Most students work hard.

For

such

x is a

,

works

.

3 Sentence: Pat knows some good movies.

For

x

,

.


Complete the paraphrases for the following ambiguous sentences with quantifiers.

1 Sentence: Every linguist knows at least two languages.

Reading 1: For

least

x such that

is a

, for every y such that

a

,

knows

.
Reading 2:

y

that

,

at least

x

is

,

.

2 Sentence: Few actors star in many movies.

Reading 1:

x

is an actor,

y is a

,

in

.
Reading 2:

y

,

is

, x

in

.


Logical forms for sentences with quantifiers

Provide the logical form of the following sentences. (Ignore the eventuality quantification.)
(Use: (i) lower case letters for variables (e,x,y,z, ...), (ii) upper case letters for predicates and name constant (LIKE, PAT, ...), (iii) capitalized words for quantifiers (Every, Most, Atleast, ..., (iv) use "*" for the bullet operator.) Note that the brackets and the "bullet operator" also count as symbols.
Example:
Sentence: Alex met some student.
Logical form: Some x (STUDENT * x : ((MEET * e) * x) * ALEX)

1 Sentence: Chris read many book.

Logical form:

x (

*

((READ

e) *

) *

)

2 Sentence: Few students know Pat.

Logical form:


Provide the logical form of the following sentences. For the solutions, mark the -seemingly emtpy- line below the sentence with your mouse.

  1. Sentence: Every student asked Alex.
    Logical form: x (studentx : ((helpe) • alex) • x)
  2. Sentence: Alex talked to Chris about many movies.
    Logical form: Many x (moviex : (((talk-to-aboute) • chris) • x) • alex)
  3. Sentence: Chomsky wrote at least four books that Alex has read.
    Logical form:

AtLeast-4 x ((bookx ∧ ((reade) • x) • alex) : ((writeu) • x) • chomsky)

LRS combinatorics for quantifiers