SolutionsGroup5: Difference between revisions
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
In this sentence, the scopal ambiguity is created by the two quantifiers "everyone" and "someone". | In this sentence, the scopal ambiguity is created by the two quantifiers "everyone" and "someone". | ||
When looking at the two pictures that try to help you, you can see two possible readings | When looking at the two pictures that try to help you, you can see two possible readings: | ||
# For every person there is, there is at least one other person who loves him / her. | # For every person there is, there is at least one other person who loves him / her. | ||
Revision as of 18:51, 20 January 2013
On this page, you can find the solutions to the excercises on Quantifiers.
Restricted Quantifiers 1a
Sorry, this is not correct.
In restricted quantifier notation, the complete noun phrase of the sentence is presented in square brackets.
Types Quantifiers 2d
[Every x: SCULPTURE(x) & MAKE (r, x)] SIGN (r, x)
Here, the N' is "sculpture he makes" and therefore belongs in square brackets together with the Quantifier "every". Since Ramon makes and signs the sculptures, the correspondng variables are (r, x).
Scopal Ambiguity 3a
In this sentence, the scopal ambiguity is created by the two quantifiers "everyone" and "someone".
When looking at the two pictures that try to help you, you can see two possible readings:
- For every person there is, there is at least one other person who loves him / her.
- There is one person that is loved by everyone else.
Restricted Quantifiers 1c
Sorry, this is not correct.
In restricted quantifier notation, the noun phrase of the sentence is presented in square brackets.
Types Quantifiers 2a
Sorry, this is not correct.
Existential quantifiers are used for sentences that represent something that exists.
Of course, you could argue that there is a Person x such that x is called Ramon and x makes (and then signs) sculptures - but this is not what we were going for.
Maybe you want to check the possible answers once more.
Types Quantifiers 2b
Yes, this is correct. (Because)
Restricted Quantifiers 1b
Yes, this is correct.
Types Quantifiers 2c
Sorry, this is not correct. (Because)
Restricted Quantifiers 1d
Sorry, this is not correct.
In restricted quantifier notation, the noun phrase of the sentence is presented in square brackets.
Scopal Ambiguity 3b
- For every person there is at least one person who loves him / her:
∀x (PERSON (x) -> ∃y (PERSON (y) & LOVE (x, y))
- There is one person that is loved by everyone:
∃x (PERSON (x) -> ∀y (PERSON (y) & LOVE (y, x))
Placeholder
This is just a placeholder in order to make sure the links work correctly, independently of the size of the PC-screen.
This is just a placeholder in order to make sure the links work correctly, independently of the size of the PC-screen.